Could Your Real Estate Agent’s Personality Cost You a House Purchase Or Sale Outcomes?
November 20, 2026
The real estate transactions feel less like buying a toaster and more like driving on a freeway…. and why your the car you drive matters
To those consumers who are not used to the world of real estate transaction, buying or selling a home feels like someone they do almost as if they were purchasing or selling a motorcycle online. You find the bike, the seller agreed to your price and boom! But in reality, I tell my clients, that buying and selling a house feels a bit like driving on a freeway. Sometimes the road is even and smooth, sometimes it is quite torn up and uneven. Sometimes it is sunny and nice. Sometimes it is pouring and foggy. Sometimes the traffic is light and everyone behaves as expected. Sometimes you find yourself sneezed between 4 powerful 18-wheelers having some kind of bad driving competition.
Now, imagine this: you are driving a car with incredibly powerful brakes but an almost useless accelerator. You might eventually reach your destination, but when? Who knows? And sometimes the inability to accelerate or keep up with other cars creates dangers of its own. Now imagine the opposite: a car with a powerful accelerator but the brakes are barely detecting your commands. You can gain a lot of speed quickly, but what happens when the traffic is slow?
Which car would you choose? Neither, of course. You need both accelerator and breaks to work properly, don’t you?
And I’ve come to believe that whether you are buying or selling a home, choosing a real estate agent (the car that will get you from here to there) involves a similar balance, in a way. Some agents naturally concentrate on finding solutions and accomplishing your objectives with speed that surprises you. Others place greater emphasis on accuracy, stability, or following established procedures, but your deadlines are slipping.
After being in real estate for many years, I came to a deepening realization that, depending on your circumstances, your agent’s natural approach can make a significant difference to your goals —and sometimes to whether you secure or lose a winning purchase or sale.
A Real-Life Example: When a Deal Gets Stuck or Off Track, Agent Personal Differences Stand Out
Recently, I represented buyers on a house that had been on the market for several months. The property they laid their eyes on was sitting vacant. The seller was living in another state, caring for elderly parents, but she was still responsible for the house’s ongoing expenses. The market in that part of town was brutal. Unsold inventory of homes was advertising large price reductions. The seller had a streak of bad luck on top of the overall weak market. Twice, her house had gone under contract. Twice, the transactions had fallen apart, reportedly because of the buyers’ circumstances rather than the property itself. My buyers were the 3rd attempt by this seller to finally get somewhere.
Again, I was representing the buyers. As we approached the end of our option period, we still had unresolved inspection concerns. It was a difficult day – the buyers had medical appointments, I had classes and appointments, the listing agent had a long time period in which she would be unavailable to act on anything. To protect my clients’ earnest money, we exercised their contractual termination right before the deadline, with their authorization, to make sure we had time to negotiate another option period extension and to continue our negotiations on the repairs.
I made sure that the listing agent knew that the buyers were still interested in exploring whether a new agreement could be reached. The listing agent surprised me by saying that she wasn’t sure we could continue discussing the transaction after termination. She needed guidance from her broker. Moreover, she strongly preferred that I would talk to my broker, too, so BOTH brokers would approve. I was taken aback, as typically such things as negotiating repairs on a home is not something I ask a permission for from my broker. But fair enough. If she felt she needed that consultation with a broker, I did not object.
But nearly 24 hours later, I texted: “Any updates? The buyers are getting restless.” Her response? “Waiting on my broker.”
I raised my eyebrows as high as they could go on my face. I imagined my actions if I were in her position. My natural response would have been: “I’m still waiting for my broker. Meanwhile, let’s confirm exactly what your buyers need to move forward. I’ll discuss the possibilities with my seller so we’re ready once the procedural questions are resolved.”
Notice the difference. Neither approach requires ignoring the need for broker review. Neither requires taking an unauthorized risk that could somehow harm the seller. But one response reports the obstacle, while the other identifies what might still be accomplished while resolving it. By approximately 3 PM the following day, the listing agent had finally spoken with her broker. Now she needed to consult her seller before discussing anything further. Meanwhile, my buyers had already scheduled showings of other houses.
I don’t know what instructions the seller had given her agent, or what the agent was doing behind the scenes.
But I knew something important: The transaction that was pretty much in the seller’s pocket just 24 hours ago was now falling apart. The consultation was moving through the agent’s process, while the buyers were starting to move away from the house altogether.
This is when I decided to write the article you are reading now.
Time Kills Deals – And Dreams
There’s a famous saying in real estate: “Time kills deals.” I’ve seen an extra half-day delay cost a seller a transaction.
Once, I was working with buyers who were deciding between two houses. I presented their proposal to my seller. It was actually a very favorable offer, and the buyers indicated that they were prepared to move on everything very quickly as their lease was ending. To me, it was a good set of cards to have in our hands. We had buyers with time pressure, so they would not play fools with repair negotiations or other tricks buyers sometimes use to create bait and switch contract.
I presented the offer to the seller, emphasizing how the buyers’ need for speedy move favored our chances of having a full price offer with limited repairs. To my surprise, he said that he wanted to think about it. Then the questions began. “Do they want the high bar chairs? Those were $250 new, but I can offer them for $200. But I could accept $170 if they could also purchase the shelves in the garage.” “How about the clock in the kitchen? Maybe they could take that plus the rug for $100?” “Do they want to keep the glasses in the bar? I would need to check on the price of those online once my wife gets home.” “Did you ask if they are taking the projector and speakers?‘
I kept encouraging him to concentrate on the major terms (price, closing costs, etc) first, so we could get the main contract signed and then we would have plenty of time to discuss the shelves or bar chairs. But he wanted to understand and calculate every detail before deciding. And while we continued peppering the buyer agent with questions about the bar chairs and the glasses and projectors, the buyers made their decision.
They purchased the other house, their agent said, not because it was better (in fact, ours was their first choice), because that other seller was ok with simply signing their offer and they did not want to wait another day to start their loan process.
My seller hadn’t necessarily rejected their proposal. He simply hadn’t decided before the opportunity disappeared.
This is something both agents and clients need to understand. While you’re thinking, analyzing, negotiating, or waiting, the mindset of your opposite party (whether they are buyers or sellers) isn’t standing still. It is constantly in motion. And the iron needs to be struck while it hot, or the strike misses the target.
And that’s where understanding different decision-making styles becomes useful.
Understanding DISC: Four Behavioral Tendencies
DISC is a behavioral framework that describes four general behavioral styles that humans, real estate agents and their brokers included, tend to display.
D — Dominance
What excites “D” personalities? Results, action, challenges, and accomplishing objectives.
I — Influence
What excites “I” personalities? Communication, enthusiasm, persuasion, and relationships.
S — Steadiness
What excites “S” personalities? Patience, cooperation, consistency, and stability.
C — Conscientiousness
What excites “C” personalities? Accuracy, analysis, understanding details, and keeping track of proper procedures.
Each style has important strengths. And each can create difficulties when its natural preferences become excessive.
- For example, a strongly results-oriented person might overlook an important detail while pursuing an objective.
- A highly analytical person might spend too much time seeking additional certainty.
- A relationship-oriented person might hesitate to confront someone.
- And a stability-oriented person might be reluctant to introduce a necessary change.
But here’s something we often overlook.
Almost Nobody Is Just One Characteristic. In Most Cases, People Combine 2 or 3 Dominant Traits
We casually describe people by saying: “She’s such a D!” “He’s definitely a C!” But real people are more complicated. Most people display a combination of DISC tendencies. Often one style is especially strong, while another provides a significant secondary influence. Some people have several relatively strong tendencies, and different DISC assessments describe these combinations differently.
And the combination can make a considerable difference.
Imagine two agents who are both strongly D-oriented. One has a strong S influence (Patience, cooperation, consistency, and stability). The other has a strong C influence (Accuracy, analysis, understanding details, and keeping track of proper procedures). They both may share a strong desire to accomplish objectives, but approach to achieving that goal might be remarkably different.
(These are examples of how tendencies might interact, not guarantees about individual behavior or professional competence.)
DISC EXAMPLE 1: D + S: Results Driven Personality Combined With Need For Cooperation (Secondary Need)
This combination may bring together the D preference for action and results with the S preference for patience, consistency, and supportive relationships. Such an agent might be especially comfortable pursuing difficult objectives while maintaining cooperation among the people involved.
DISC EXAMPLE 2: D + C: Results Driven Personality Combined With Need ForAnalysis And Process Enforcement (Secondary Need)
This combination may bring together decisiveness and an appetite for challenges with careful investigation, technical accuracy, and structured planning. Such an agent might prefer developing a detailed strategy before executing it in a very structured and step-by-step manner.
DISC EXAMPLE 3: I + S: Relationship Driven Personality Combined With Need For Cooperation (Secondary Need)
This combination may emphasize relationship-building, trust, encouragement, and patient guidance. It could be particularly comfortable for clients who value frequent communication, warm relationship, and reassurance.
DISC EXAMPLE 4: I + S: Relationship Driven Personality Combined With Need For Analysis And Process Enforcement (Secondary Need)
This combination may bring together persuasive communication and relationship-building with careful analysis and attention to details. It could be valuable when complicated information must be examined carefully and certain processes followed in certain sequence for a process to succeed.
And the relative strength of each tendency matters, too. Someone whose strongest tendency is a very strong D, followed by weaker S, may approach decisions differently from someone whose strongest tendency is strong S, followed by weaker D.
Four letters can create many combinations. And those combinations help explain why two agents with similar professional backgrounds can have very different working styles.
How I See These Differences On Display in My Own Work In Real Estate
My own DISC results show a very strong D tendency, supported by a strong S tendency. I often joke that I inherited two very different approaches from my parents. My father was an engineer (a very strong S with supporting C). My mother was a talented teacher (a very strong I) and busy school administrator (a fairly strong D).
One side of my upbringing emphasized analytical thinking and understanding constraints. The other exposed me to coordinating people, negotiating complicated trade offs, keeping multiple parties engaged and happy, and keeping things moving no matter snow, rain, or fire. I see those influences in how I approach difficult real estate transactions.
I naturally begin with understanding the overall objective (my D side takes care of that). What are we trying to accomplish?
Then I break down the obstacles into segments (my S side takes care of that part), check out everyone’s ideas and opinions, identify possible areas of agreement, work with the parties involved, and consult my broker or appropriate specialists to make sure the solution can be implemented correctly.
The result? I am one of the top 10% of all agents in my office. My broker has repeatedly asked me to help other agents with unusually complicated transactions. Sometimes the problem involves unusual financing. Sometimes it involves difficult negotiations or contractual arrangements that don’t fit the conventional approach.
Why am I often the agent to handle complicated or unusual set of obstacles? Because my instinct isn’t immediately to conclude that something cannot be done simply because the usual procedure doesn’t address it. It’s to ask whether there’s another lawful, workable way to accomplish the objective that no one has considered yet (this is the D behavior). On the other hand, I also understand that finding a creative solution isn’t sufficient. We need to evaluate its risks, confirm the requirements, and document everything appropriately (this is the S and C territory).
That’s why I don’t believe a person’s DISC profile is a limitation on what they’re capable of doing. Natural tendencies matter, but experience, professional knowledge, and learned skills matter enormously too.
When Does DISC Actually Matter in Real Estate?
This brings us to a practical question. Would the ideal agent for an ordinary, straightforward purchase necessarily be the best choice for an unusually complicated transaction? Not always. For a very simple, straightforward transaction with little to negotiate and no hidden issues, almost any agent could do a decent job.
But many real life real estate transactions are not smooth or easy, and THAT is the time when the differences in the agent personalities can make a big difference.
A transaction with unusual financing or complex challenges: A buyer has a complicated income situation or needs a financing arrangement that doesn’t fit the standard approach. The transaction may particularly benefit from someone who enjoys solving problems, coordinating people, and exploring legitimate alternatives. D and I tendencies might contribute useful strengths here, supported by careful analysis and lending expertise.
A property with complicated legal or city compliance concerns that require close cooperation with courts, builders, city officials, or legal paperwork. For this transaction, you may particularly appreciate an agent who enjoys technical investigation, detailed analysis, slow and deliberate process, and questioning assumptions. Strong C-related tendencies could be valuable, especially when combined with the ability to turn the detailed findings into actual progress.
A highly competitive housing market: You’re a buyer in a sellers’ market (competing with other buyers) or you are a seller in a buyers’ market (you are competing with other sellers for buyers). An agent who is comfortable making quick deals, negotiating, and communicating effectively may be particularly valuable. D and I strengths could be useful.
A first-time buyer who feels overwhelmed. The buyer is anxious, unfamiliar with the process, and needs time to understand decisions. Patience, consistency, empathy, and clear communication may be especially important. S and I strengths could be particularly helpful.
The important point is that different transactions demand different strengths.
And your own preferences are only half the equation.
A Quick Self-Check: What’s Your Natural Style?
Self test 1: Imagine walking into a house that you absolutely love. What’s your first instinct?
- D: “This is it! What do we need to do to get this house?”
- I: “I love it! Imagine having our friends and family over!”
- S: “I really like it, but let’s make sure we’re comfortable before committing.”
- C: “Let’s review the price, condition, and potential expenses, and then maybe we will move forward.”
Self test 2: Now imagine an unexpected problem appears during negotiations. What frustrates you most?
- D: Nobody seems to be working toward a solution. Can’t we make at least some progress so we do not lose momentum?
- I: Communication between everyone has broken down. We need to re-establish good communication and avoid unnecessary conflicts.
- S: Everything suddenly feels unpredictable and stressful. We lack structure and goalposts for this process.
- C: Decisions are being made without enough information. We need to slow down and analyze everything before making any additional decisions.
Which answers sound most like you?
You might recognize one dominant tendency, or perhaps two. That’s normal. This is a reflection exercise, not a formal DISC assessment. The idea is simply to recognize what matters most to you when making decisions.
Should Your Agent’s Personality Be Similar to Yours?
Not necessarily.
For example. In my own marriage, I’m often the driver and the catalyst of many changes or ideas. My husband is frequently the stabilizer who listens, breaks down my ideas, does hours of research, and plans out the steps. I tend to recognize opportunities and explore possibilities. He is more inclined to investigate the details, calculate alternatives, and evaluate risks.
Sometimes his careful analysis makes me reconsider a decision. Sometimes my willingness to explore possibilities helps us recognize opportunities we might otherwise overlook. We benefit from those differences. But that doesn’t mean every D-oriented buyer should hire a C-oriented agent, or every S-oriented buyer should hire a D. Remember, we’re dealing with combinations rather than single letters. And two people with similar profiles can work exceptionally well together.
The goal isn’t necessarily to find your opposite. It’s to find someone whose strengths and working style complement your own needs and the challenges of your transaction.
Two Questions to Ask Before Hiring an Agent
You probably won’t be able to identify an agent’s exact DISC profile in a short interview. And even if you could, that wouldn’t guarantee how they would perform. But you can ask questions that reveal something about how they approach problems.
Potential Question 1. “Suppose we’re negotiating a transaction, but something outside your control is preventing us from moving forward. What would you do?”
- Does the agent describe the obstacle?
- Do they talk about communicating with the people involved?
- Do they look for alternative solutions?
- Do they identify what can still be accomplished while waiting?
- Do they explain how they would verify the appropriate next steps?
Their response might reveal the combination of behavioral strengths they naturally rely upon. More importantly, you may recognize whether their approach sounds useful to you.
Potential Question 2. “Tell me about a difficult transaction where the conventional approach didn’t work. How did you solve it?”
This question can be especially revealing if your own transaction has unusual circumstances. Listen for how the agent describes the problem, what alternatives they considered, how they coordinated the parties, and how they managed the risks. You aren’t looking for someone who simply claims to be creative or careful. You’re looking for an explanation that makes sense to you. And perhaps you’ll recognize whether this is someone you’d feel comfortable working with when your own transaction becomes complicated.
Back to the Accelerator and the Brakes
A powerful accelerator (D or I type of traits) is valuable. So are excellent brakes (S and C types of traits). Neither is inherently good or bad. Their usefulness depends on the circumstances. The same is true of the four DISC tendencies.
- Results-oriented thinking can help preserve opportunities.
- Careful analysis can prevent costly mistakes.
- Strong communication can keep negotiations productive.
- Patience and stability can help clients navigate stressful decisions.
And many people bring meaningful combinations of those strengths. So before hiring a real estate agent, consider three things: Your personality. Your transaction’s likely challenges. And the way your prospective agent approaches problems.
No DISC assessment can guarantee a successful transaction. But understanding these differences may help you recognize a professional relationship that works well for you.
Because you’re not simply hiring someone who knows how to buy or sell houses. You’re choosing a person whose way of thinking can influence what happens when things don’t go according to plan.



